Simms Defends His Quarterbacks in their Prime List
Pro-Football Talks Chris Simms stopped by to explain the thought process behind his viral quarterback rankings, which focused on each player’s peak rather than career accomplishments. Simms argued that team success often clouds individual greatness, pointing to Peyton Manning’s ability to strike fear into opposing defenses regardless of postseason results. He also explained why separating quarterbacks from their supporting casts changes the conversation, creating a very different list than a traditional greatest-of-all-time ranking.